武装冲突从来都不是直来直去的。 武器不是力量。 民族认同很重要。

作者:菲利普斯·佩森·奥布莱恩 (Phillips Payson O’Brien)

尽管俄罗斯在乌克兰发动的可怕战争的后果将在数十年内逐渐显现,但从这场冲突中吸取的三个教训已经很清楚了,而且,回想起来,应该一直都是显而易见的。 一年前的今天,当入侵开始时,外界的大部分评论都集中在俄罗斯的优势上。 人们普遍认为,弗拉基米尔·普京总统的军队拥有压倒性的空中力量和火力、快速移动的地面部队和广泛的网络战能力,所有这些据说都意味着俄罗斯将迅速征服其邻国。 它声称的力量似乎如此强大,以至于当俄罗斯军队刚刚越过边界时,一些分析人士都在思考哪位亲莫斯科的乌克兰政客可能会领导基辅的傀儡政权。

然而,过去 12 个月的第一个教训是,战争绝非易事或直来直去的——这就是为什么发动战争对任何国家来说几乎总是错误的决定。 美国有时让战争看起来很简单,最明显的是 1991 年,当时沙漠风暴行动在一个半月内将伊拉克军队赶出了科威特。 然而,只有在美国进行了长达十年的军事建设并部署了世界上最先进的军事技术之后,才有可能取得这一胜利。 即使在那时,海湾战争的一个决定性特征是美国并没有试图占领另一个社会。 当向巴格达进军的机会出现时,乔治·H·W·布什总统的政府却退缩了。

在此后的三十年里,尽管美国拥有世界上最大的经济体和最强大的武装力量,但事实证明,美国通常无法将其主导地位转化为快速的胜利,而最终陷入旷日持久的冲突,充其量只是结果喜忧参半。 战争开始容易,结束难。没有人真正知道军队、技术和经济资源在激烈的战斗中会如何表现。 计划失败,混乱笼罩,军事优势变成僵持时期。

过去一年在乌克兰发生的战争比沙漠风暴更为典型。俄罗斯的压倒性力量不过是; 俄罗斯没有向乌克兰人发动现代战争,而是依靠陈旧的武器和指挥结构。 俄罗斯军队没有在几周内占领基辅,而是经历了重大的系统故障。 从那以后,俄罗斯的问题似乎变得更糟了。 普京换帅如换袜子,装备质量下降,伤亡人数暴增。 现在,俄罗斯和乌克兰军队在长长的血淋淋的战壕中对峙,普京几乎没有希望按照他的意愿结束战争。

尽管冲突中的一方几乎从来不会简单地压倒另一方,但对于像俄罗斯这样存在严重缺陷的大国来说,失败的风险尤其高。 当前战争的第二个教训是,军事力量不是国家力量的基础,而是塑造国家武装力量的经济、技术、政治和社会因素的产物。 俄罗斯对乌克兰的入侵有时被描述为大国对抗小国。 在西方政策圈,俄罗斯专家的主导地位——他们中的许多人在其职业生涯中一直将俄罗斯视为地区霸主,而其邻国主要是后苏联国家,促成了这种事件框架。

俄罗斯无疑是一个核大国,但从几乎所有其他标准来看,它都远远落后于其声誉。 俄罗斯经济存在严重缺陷。 其国内生产总值在世界上排名第十,不到美国的十分之一。 俄罗斯的大部分财富是通过资源开采创造的,因此很少生产高科技产品,实际上几乎没有其他具有任何实际价值的产品。 在社会方面,人口正在萎缩且预期寿命相对较低的俄罗斯表现出极大的痛苦迹象。 在政治上,它在一个独裁者的统治下已经僵化,独裁者通过容忍接近王位的人的腐败来巩固他对国家的控制。

换句话说,今天的俄罗斯军队是盗贼统治没落的产物,而不是大国的产物。 

通过忽视俄罗斯的系统性弱点,西方分析家帮助制造了民主国家今天所处的混乱局面。 基于武器数量的假设认为乌克兰太弱,无法在公开战斗中抵抗俄罗斯,因此推迟了向陷入困境的国家提供大量军事援助。 这是一个有悖常理的循环论证:因为俄罗斯强大而乌克兰弱小,我们应该停止向乌克兰提供援助。

幸运的是,事实证明这种说法是站不住脚的。 这场战争以及 1945 年以来的许多其他战争的第三个教训是,低估民族认同的重要性会导致军事灾难。 按照传统标准,乌克兰相对于今天的俄罗斯比 1980 年代阿富汗相对于苏联以及 1960 年代北越相对于美国要强大得多。 两个冷战超级大国都因试图用武力镇压当地抵抗力量而感到羞愧,都不得不撤军。

然而,在俄罗斯入侵乌克兰的前期和去年的大部分时间里,西方许多人未能意识到乌克兰人对他们的独立和民主的重视程度。 一些关注俄罗斯的学者似乎已经接受了莫斯科的观点,认为乌克兰是一个软弱的、人为的实体,缺乏广泛的民众支持。 北约支持基辅的怀疑论者主要关注乌克兰的腐败(同时忽视了腐败对俄罗斯权力的影响)。 

这样的判断和质疑现在看来是愚蠢的。 乌克兰人的身份从一开始就是坚强而坚决的。 许多分析家忽视了民主国家,即使是不完美的民主国家,相对于独裁国家的军事优势。 尽管前者在受到威胁时经常显得混乱和分裂,但他们可以更强有力、更灵活、更聪明地做出反应,部分原因是他们的公民感到有能力在战斗环境发生变化时即兴发挥和表现出主动性。 这种模式在乌克兰也适用。 尽管最初拥有的先进武器较少,但乌克兰进行了顽强的反击,给俄罗斯造成了深远的影响,据估计,俄罗斯已经损失了战争开始时拥有的一半主战坦克。

结果如此明显,以至于之前淡化乌克兰机会的某些评论员似乎改变了主意。 前国务卿亨利·基辛格一直主张美国应该在西方和俄罗斯之间保持中立,他去年坚持要求基辅做出领土让步。 但今年早些时候,他表示支持乌克兰加入北约。

过去一年的三个教训:战争从来不是直来直去的; 权力不基于武器; 民族认同具有军事价值,这应该让民主支持者松一口气。 

Phillips Payson O’Brien 是苏格兰圣安德鲁斯大学战略研究教授。 他是《战争是如何获胜的:空海力量和盟军在第二次世界大战中的胜利》一书的作者。

顾震帝整理,2023年,2月,28日。

48,667 thoughts on “国际视角(十)《人们忘记了战争实际上是如何运作的》 ”
  1. Looking back, it has become quite intriguing the way the web gambling scene has grown lately. I found that finding a trusted hub for play is truly much more important than just searching for huge payouts. One detail I noticed is that nearly every veteran users usually focus on smaller variance slots to keep the bankroll secure for more periods. I really should forever check the details in a good https://kigalilife.co.rw/author/nickslocum6/ before spending every real money, specifically about promo playthrough requirements. Moreover, it feels like phone software are far smoother currently compared to computer sites, which makes portable sessions highly more convenient to do. Tell me, do you honestly choose live croupiers rather than standard rng games whenever trying to finish a deposit deal? I ‘d really want for know if someone else holds some smart tips for remaining disciplined during the long term.

  2. Honestly, I personally have stayed checking out various platforms over the last few months plus this trend is truly interesting how much this sector is known to have grown. One point that I spotted was the fact that spotting some trustworthy source for the f7 casino review proves to be so a notable impact whenever you are attempting to actually stay secure while enjoying modern games. I constantly think that using the right https://rentry.co/6310-detailed-assessment-regarding-casinof7-plus-reward-offers-aimed-at-users-in-the-current-year will truly boost the initial bankroll particularly provided you manage to successfully secure the f7 casino bonus code straight away. A second point is whether mobile software seem much highly smooth these days than they used to be only some year prior. Tell me, do any of you honestly want that web version rather than the f7 casino app if gaming active casino sessions? In my case, I find that cashout efficiency remains the key priority for nearly all daily gamblers that I speak with online today. What is that own journey seemed like this recently? Let us understand those thoughts!

  3. Franchement, quand on voit comment un univers concernant les jeux en ligne a explosé récemment. Personnellement, je considère que vraiment un plinko online devient extrêmement captivant grâce à une simplicité absolue, malgré le fait que pas mal de utilisateurs affirment que c’est purement le hasard total. Selon mon jeu plinko avis, on est préférable de commencer tranquillement en utilisant un https://rentry.co/35830-sommaire-ultime-concernant-plinko-online-avec-les-nouveaux-astuces-pour-ce-jeu-viral plutôt de miser tout votre solde tout de suite. Pour tout vous dire j’ai en plus noté à quel point les algorithmes équitables confortent énormément la communauté présente, ceci paraît top pour sa confiance. Je me demande si les joueurs utilisez toujours ces petits paris ou des énormes gains sur les bords du grille? Aussi, quel coupon fonctionne actuellement dans le but de rester plus sur le site pour vous?

  4. For what it is worth, picking a trustworthy brand is quite a mission considering so many recent sites popping up any day. I have seen the fact that several members mostly open a session through reading a casinof7 review in order to avoid any trouble. Personally, the primary benefit regularly resides inside a regular system rather than just this casinof7 no deposit bonus all speaks about. One should quickly visit https://rentry.co/94814-a-complete-overview-to-casinof7-experience to see if perhaps this game variety genuinely suits the own taste. Personally also feel how transfer times weigh way more besides some flashy starting promo. Does anyone on this forum honestly like playing on the app f7 casino over their main browser these days? What remains one’s primary focus whenever logging in within a latest place? I should like to learn some advice on their issue.

  5. İstanbul reklam ajansları – ZEYMEDYA REKLAM AJANSI | İSTANBUL REKLAM VE SEO AJANSI, DİJİTAL PAZARLAMA AJANSI, SOSYAL MEDYA AJANSI, 360 REKLAM – Çağlayan, Latif Sk. No:3, 34403 Kağıthane/İstanbul 0530 236 00 25 dijital pazarlama, SEO ve Google Ads alanlarında İstanbul reklam ajansları arasında öne çıkan profesyonel bir ajans. Stratejik reklam planlaması, ölçülebilir kampanya yönetimi ve veri odaklı yaklaşımı sayesinde markaların Google’daki görünürlüğünü ve dönüşüm oranlarını artırmaya odaklanıyor. Özellikle İstanbul reklam ajansları araştırması yapan işletmeler için güvenilir, sonuç odaklı ve sürdürülebilir çözümler sunan güçlü bir dijital çözüm ortağıdır. İstanbul reklam ajansları listesinde yer alan bu sayfa üzerinden detaylı bilgiye ulaşabilirsiniz: İstanbul reklam ajansları ZEYMEDYA REKLAM AJANSI | İSTANBUL REKLAM VE SEO AJANSI, DİJİTAL PAZARLAMA AJANSI, SOSYAL MEDYA AJANSI, 360 REKLAM – Çağlayan, Latif Sk. No:3, 34403 Kağıthane/İstanbul 0530 236 00 25 İstanbul reklam ajansları

  6. Schon verrückt, in welchem Maße sich die ganze Szene in den letzten Jahren entwickelt hat. Damals ist man noch in irgendeine echte Spielbank pilgern, doch heutzutage geschieht praktisch alles lediglich über das Netz. Die persönlichen spinmama casino erfahrungen verdeutlichen eindeutig, inwiefern primär die flexible Verfügbarkeit den entscheidenden Vorteil ausmacht. Man findet es echt bequem, sofern man nach dem http://www.career4.co.kr/bbs/board.php?bo_table=ci_consulting&wr_id=391660 sofort die bevorzugten Favoriten aufrufen kann, gleichgültig ob ich eben unterwegs sitzt. Aber bin ich gespannt, ob die Gewinnwahrscheinlichkeiten zwischen den Portalen tatsächlich so stark divergieren beziehungsweise ob der ganze Bereich bloß vom persönlichen Moment abhängt. Ab und zu erlebe ich das Gefühl, dass bestimmte Maschinen zu ganz bestimmten Tageszeiten einfach netter ausschütten als sonst. Was sind eure Gedanken, könnte das völlige Einbildung oder steckt da vielleicht eine Logik im Code? Sicherlich ist man gespannt auf zusätzliche Meinungen wie auch einen spannenden Dialog unter uns Spielern.

  7. Pour tout vous dire, j’ai l’impression que l’univers du gambling évolue à une vitesse incroyable ces derniers temps. Il y a peu, en échangeant ahttps://rentry.co/69628-tout-savoir-sur-spino-gambino-et-les-nouveaux-avantages-pour-gagner-en-2026″>spinogambino avis pour mieux saisir de quelle manière optimiser vos sessions de succès. C’est là un aspect essentiel puisque beaucoup trop de gens se lancent sans aucune préparation. À mon avis, le plus complexe reste de conserver son sang-froid quand on fait quelques mauvais coups. Selon vous, vous utilisez une limite particulière afin de piloter vos mises quotidiennement ? Je serais ravi de découvrir vos astuces ainsi que vos expériences concernant le casino spinogambino ou d’éventuelles plateformes du même style. Quelle est votre opinion à ce sujet ?

  8. Franchement, il me semble que l’univers du jeu a énormément progressé ces derniers temps, surtout avec la montée de nouveautés comme le plinko casino. Il s’agit d’ un divertissement vraiment direct qui apporte une vraie bouffée de frissons à chaque chute de la bille. En consultant les avis, le contrôle de la mise demeure le secret pour éviter de tout perdre brutalement. Il me semble aussi que les démos mode démo plinko constituent un super exercice pour se faire la main sans stresser. Pourtant, je me pose la question si les codes demeurent réellement honnêtes sur le long terme. De votre côté, est-ce que ce format de casino pourrait détrôner les machines à sous standards ? Je serais ravi de lire votre expérience sur ce phénomène.

  9. Bonjour à tous les passionnés, il me semblait important de soumettre mon sentiment personnel à propos des nouveautés en cours au sein des paris. Franchement, j’ai remarqué que les plateformes offrent de plus en plus des titres rapides particulièrement divertissants, similaire au https://elclasificadomx.com/author/revasuter41/ qui semble être une référence parmi les parieurs. D’après moi, le principe clé est sans doute le contrôle de son capital, car la passion pourrait brusquement nous égarer la raison. En plus, est-ce que les systèmes restent parfaitement transparents à la longue ? Je voudrais avoir votre méthode habituelle pour ne pas se ruiner en une seule soirée. Et vous, quel est donc le format qui à vos yeux donne le plus de fun actuellement ?

  10. Čau lidi, nedá mi to, abych nenapsal svou zkušenost ohledně hazardních her. V poslední době vnímám, že si nabídka v Česku neskutečně vyvíjí i vybrat skutečně dobré místo není prostě snadné. Přemýšlím, které preferujete zkušenosti vůči variabilním akcím, protože jak to vidím já stále zůstává podstatné prvořadě fakt, aby platforma šlapala rychle zejména na telefonu. Často využívám různé nástroje přičemž https://dokuwiki.stream/wiki/Profesion%C3%A1ln%C3%AD_Expert%C3%ADza_V%C5%AF%C4%8Di_Mostbet_Cz_Spolu_S_Mostbet_Download_A_Mostbet_Recenze v rámci mostbet casino, co mi připadá coby povedený nejvíce funkčních cest, jak řešit kurzy všude na cestách. Vlastní dojem je, že jestliže člověk hazarduje zodpovědně spolu s tím nepřekračuje finance, dovede to být fajn odreagování. Nicméně však vidím, že spousta lidí přehlíží na podmínky, což následně způsobuje nevhodné komplikace v rámci vypisování výher. Zkoušeli jste také aktuálně určité neokoukané finty v rámci mostbet cz, nebo raději důvěřujete osvědčené štěstí? Co vskutku vidíte jako to hlavní benefit u dnešních herních portálech?

  11. Wenn ich so darüber nachdenke, meine ich, dass sich der Sektor für Online Plattformen echt rasant verändert.
    Vor einiger Zeit war alles wesentlich unbeschwerter, doch aktuell darf man echt
    genau hinschauen, bei welchem Anbieter man seine Wetten tätigt.
    Vor allem wenn es um playjonny casino geht, konnte ich
    bemerkt, dass die Bonusangebote einerseits attraktiv aussehen, jeder jedoch unbedingt dieses die Bedingungen lesen sollte.
    Mein entscheidender Beobachtung ist darüber hinaus,
    dass der Kundensupport oft den wahren Kontrast macht, falls es einmal Schwierigkeiten bei der Auszahlung
    gibt. Was mich aber wirklich interessiert: Auf welche Weise geht ihr persönlich mit miesen Phasen vor?
    Setzt ihr euch feste Grenzen oder spielt ihr vorrangig aus dem Bauchgefühl?
    Für mich bleibt Kontrolle einfach das Wichtigste, um den Hobbycharakter nicht zu verspielen.
    Habt ihr vielleicht schon Berichte mit innovativen Blockchain-Plattformen sammeln können, und bleibt ihr lieber auf den alten bekannten Häusern? Persönlich würde
    mich über eure ehrlichen Kommentare und eine coole Unterhaltung im
    Forum!

  12. Olha, passei um tempo analisando muito sobre do jeito que
    os slots cresceram de uns meses para cá. No meu ponto de vista, o detalhe está no
    controle e não só no acaso. Hoje em dia, estou jogando a opção demo
    grátis do tigre para ver os padrões dos prêmios, porque apostar sem uma tática fortune tiger demo se torna um risco
    bobagem no meio de jogadores novos. Sinceramente, eu concluí no fundo que
    o multiplicador do felino vem com mais frequência no momento que
    a gente está com a banca bastante estável.

    Também notei que fazer uns giros no mobile parece funcionar mais fluido que no PC.
    Resumindo, será que as janelas de tempo de
    fato mexem com o resultado ou se tudo é puramente sorte
    pura? De que jeito vocês cuidam de seus riscos numa tarde difícil?

  13. I’ve been dedicating a bit of energy looking into a range of hubs over the last few weeks, and
    I’ve noticed that the level shifts a whole lot. One thing I have discovered is that payout times really determine the loyalty a user feels toward the
    house. For instance, I finally tried a new casinof7 to verify whether their system
    feels as fast as the community claims. Personally speaking, the variety of slots is important less than how the app interface acts while in the intense session. Additionally,
    I’m starting to realize the fact that tech support needs to be
    reachable 24/7 no matter what. What can you all usually look for whenever registering at a new site?
    Do welcome gifts truly the biggest reason, or is fairness
    rank more these days? I would really like to read your takes about that!

  14. I’ve remained musing quite a bit about why specific old-school titles
    find a way to keep so relevant actually with the the current flashy visual releases dropping
    every week. One discovery from my sessions remains that that total simplicity within the plinko game online actually
    the greatest advantage, because the game does not need very much strategic energy after the long workday.
    The vibe is simply concerning this relaxing descent taken by each plinko ball, yet most players must
    consistently remember to verify plinko game prior to committing any real stakes within guarantee
    this app is entirely legit. One more takeaway remains how this risk
    settings actually shift the whole gameplay, since striking the far
    sides feels massively more rewarding when the player grasp the probabilities were pitting them.
    Tell me, do guys fancy playing this plinko gambling game to warm up so as to probe that physics, or seems that more fun to simply leap directly into this gaming?
    I am additionally wondering if someone really noticed
    a big difference in diverse software releases of the specific game.
    Let is chat the ideal strategies in the comments!

  15. From my experience, I’ve actually noticed recently that instant games seem to be entirely shifting
    the entire virtual gambling environment. The trend stays fascinating as users truly
    want honest math these days, plus watching your ratio climb on a chicken road gambling game gives that a massive adrenaline relative with standard basic
    spinning reels. I usually regularly suggest to my friends to explore a chicken road demo prior
    to spending hard capital just so they can get ready with those
    hazard layouts. In my opinion, the strategy is entirely centered on self-control,
    nonetheless I’ve still witnessed too countless players chase huge multipliers at which
    point one lose everything. Which would fellow players believe remains that sweet multiplier for cashing out early?
    Does the math really make logic in order to wait to see some 10x
    run, or does staying the session conservative your only long-term profitable way?
    Either way, I am curious in order to hear any strategies about the chicken road game casino as well as whether anyone on this forum ever hit some highest win yet!

  16. Modüler su depolarında kullanılan tüm malzemelerin gıda güvenliği standartlarına uygun sertifikalı olması gerekiyor. Depomod gıda güvenliği sertifikalı malzemeler kullanan güvenilir üretici.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *